BrightEye said:
Anyway, I was wondering if any of you use 'historical decks', such as Vacchetta, Mitelli, Sola Busca, or Ancient Minchiate for sitters in face-to-face readings. If you do, how do people take to them? And if you don't, why don't you?
Yup.
What I tend to do is have a few decks on display, the same Major Arcana card uppermost so that clients can pick the style of artwork they are most comfortable with. Most people will go with whatever they find visually appealing, and of those, most will go with modern decks (although two weeks ago, I had a red-letter day when my mini-Visconti was chosen by every single person).
There are some people, a small minority, who will completely disregard whatever their tastes lead them to, in favour of "authenticity". Of them, the vast majority have only ever heard of or seen images from the Rider-Waite, so they head unerringly towards that.
After a recent discussion, I think, in "using tarot" or possibly here, I started asking people who chose the RW, why they had made that choice, and it was all about using a "proper" or "authentic" or "old" Tarot deck. I have taken delight in pointing to the Visconti as 500 years older.
Who me? <innocent look> Mischievous? Not a chance.
The day the Visconti was incredibly popular, though, was all about it being particularly charming that day - even I noticed it and I'm a bit blase about my decks.