Review on The Changeling of Finnistuath
O.K., I just finished the Changeling of Finnistuath last night.
First, this book needs a slight warning, as quoted from another favorite author, Christopher Moore: "If you're buying this book as a gift for your grandma or a kid, you should be aware that it contains cusswords as well as ...depictions of...people having sex." In fact, at first I wondered a bit how this one got into the public library, until I saw how masterfully the author wrote the whole of this book.
The sex is what my grandma would definitely call "saucy," for even an age-appropriate reading audience. But the sex isn't gratuitous--it honestly serves both the plot and enhances your understanding of the characters.
The language is explicit and starts as early as the first sentence in the book. Caution notwithstanding, I think the language of the book is probably pretty accurate to the time period, though.
This book meets and exceeds her first book in that there is much better editing (with the exception of probably the last 30-odd pages,) very well-developed characters and nice attention to historical detail. She paints such strong descriptions that you can't help but to feel you're part of the landscape. By the end of the book you feel like you know these characters so well and that the characters are so emotionally/intellectually/spiritually strong that you'd love to sit down over a hot cup of matcha with them. Again, it's a book full of true-isms. It's as if you're getting knowlege for living and surviving life from the school-of-hard-knocks, as told by some smokey, fern-covered village's wise woman. It's a book about transformations in a person's self-peception, interacting with a world who seeks to judge and use others for their own aims, the nature of Nature, and about what constitutes a true family. It still straddles the old ways and mixes them with the early roots of Christianity, but as a diaphonous inner struggle where the characters try to identitify as much as who they in relation to what they believe as well as trying to figure out who they are within a quickly changing culture. This book is much more of a hero's journey than the last--central characters take on mythic proportions. Definitely an adventure worth taking!
I'd give it 5*****