I started learning through a free online course. They sent a new lesson each week, homework...Honestly, it was a wrong path for me. And I am sure most newbies hit upon a few wrong paths until they find their right one.
My first deck was the Haindl. It was not the "traditional" kind of learning deck, but I would not have changed a thing about that. If I could start again I very much start again with that deck.
The thing is that the online lessons did not correspond very well with the deck I had. They were sending me the meanings of the cards to learn. And I noticed very very quickly that the standard meanings of the card they were giving me were not at all what the cards in my deck meant...the images were not comparable either, especially in the Minors.
I think for me this gave me a healthy skepticism of preset meanings and keywords. Now, for others memorizing meanings ....may be their path, but it was not mine and I beleive that the universe always sends each of us what we need when we need it to find our own right paths.
And my Haindl also mentions a lot about chakras....all kinds if things I never had heard of, so that sent me off to study up on them....all were useful to me. And It has I-Ching symbols, Hebrew letters and Runes too. I guess that was were I started to get interested in the I-Ching and Runes as well.
Also my Haindl is a very environmentally conscious deck. Much of it's philosophy embodies caring for the environment and helping fix it. I think that taught me a lot of how I feel now about the connection to the universe and our planet that I have always seen Tarot as bringing into my life. I think maybe that was one of the things that helped cement my connection between the two in my mind as I was staring to learn to read.
Anyway, since the meanings in that course and in my deck differed so, I started reading about how important book meanings where, when it was alright to discard them...And now, honestly I hardly use thebook meanings at all, because all this lead me to learn how to read intuitively and not follow the books.
Ok, I guess you can tell that I love my first deck. And I honestly believe the best learning deck is the one you feel drawn to...doesn't have to be what someone else suggests, just follow your heart. Of course I love all my decks now, all 24.
And that was the best thing for me. Yes, it works very well for me. And I adore doing it. It's magical.
Oh and yes, my journals have been invaluable. You wouldnt beleive how much I have written and copied and pasted from web sites. All of it's been useful and I still read it over often. It taught me so much about Tarot and about myself as well. My readings I have kept there and read over have changed my life, very literally and in deep and wonderful ways.
Personally, I like you idea. I wouldn't throw a book out. It could happen you want to look something up years from now. But basically I find that books on technique and how to read can be invaluable, but the book meanings do not mean as much as meanings you find within your self and your heart and soul. I rarely consult book meanings at all. I do for two of my decks....The Osho Zen Tarot and the Tao Oracle. This is because these decks embrace and build on Zen and Taoist philosphies, both of which I currently know nothing about and reading the texts teaches that. But otherwise I ignore book meanings.
Babs