two different interpretations of this spread... need your help

[tompl]

1 Kats intentions towards You x1- Knight of swords
2 Her expectations towards you x1- 6 pentacles
3 How she sees You x1- 3 swords
4 What she can give You x1- Page of cups
5 Her attitude towards You x1- King of cups
6 What she hides x3, 5 swords, 10 swords, Priestess
7 Your expectations x1- 2 cups.
8 What can You give x1 - Ace of wands
9 Relationship at the moment x1 Emperor
10 Her actions towards You in next month x3- 10 of wands, 8 pentacles, Empress
11 Where is this relation going ? 9 of cups, Chariot, Star

So we've been debating over this spread with a good friend of mine. It was done for a person who's in relationship in crisis. For me the woman is clearly hiding something nasty and is thinking of dumping the guy (knight of swords, 5 swords, 10 swords) She sees him as a potential partner(king of cups) but she cares only for her own good. Guy is looking for a mature relationship (2 of cups)

Our opinion differ in last point. For me these are clearly good cards. everything will end good. My friend thinks that she will dump him and star represents only his dreams.
What is Your opinion?

[tompl]

help anyone??

[Glass Owl]

Hi, Tompl, welcome to AT.

The reason why your post probably isn't getting any responses is because this area is actually reserved for the posting of Tarot spreads, not for actual readings. If you would like some assistance with your reading you can post it (along with your interpretation of all of the cards in your reading) in the Your Readings forum of AT.

Before posting in Your Readings forum though I would recommend that you read through that forum's guidelines so that you can get a feel for how that forum works.

For instance, since Your Readings is a learning forum you will need to include some basic information that will aid us in assisting you, such as what deck you used as well as the spread you used along with the position meanings. Plus, you will need to provide your own interpretations of each card. Simply posting the cards could be interpreted as asking for a free reading and your thread may be deleted by a moderator as a result. If you have no resources for card meanings, you may want to take a look at this page.

Be sure to also provide some feedback in your thread when others generously take the time to help with your reading. This way we can all learn and grow together.

Good luck and once again, welcome to AT.

[tompl]

thanks will be more careful in the future