Fame

Ross G Caldwell

Hi Huck,

I'll have to look at Panormita's account of the Trionfo again, but I think not these particular seven, but some of them and others appeared in the Trionfo.

Fortune gave him a lecture - she was higher and in the middle of the virtues.

You can read Burckhardt's account of it - I think he gives this part in detail.

"in carta" here I think means "on paper" - that is "in writing", it will be written down forever.

But I'll come back later with more, if Marco or someone else doesn't get to it first.

Ross
 

Rosanne

Thanks for the explanation Ross ! It is obviously nothing to do with Renaissance Cloth either :D
~Rosanne
 

Ross G Caldwell

Hi Huck,

here's where my memory screwed up. Panormita says in the description
http://www.bibliotecaitaliana.it/xtf/view?docId=bibit001050/bibit001050.xml

that Fortune (here conflated with Opportunity, as we later know her, with a forelock and bald behind) was followed by "six" virtues, and then proceeds to list *seven* - Hope, Faith, Charity, Fortitude, Temperance, Prudence, followed later by Justice, to emphasize her importance.

Caesar comes next, and mentions the seven virtues.

Later on, a giant tower comes surrounded by four further virtues, Magnanimitas, Constantia, Clementia, and Liberalitas.

Fame, by that name, is nowhere to be found (at least in my quick reading), but Julius Caesar (as mentioned by Burckhardt), who comes between Fortune with the virtues and the tower with four others, clearly symbolizes Fame (he is standing on a rotaing globe and declares "Behold both this changeful world and everything else unsure, except virtue." (Ecce et mundus volubilis et praeter virtutem omnia incerta).

Ubi sunt qui ante nos fuerunt (except for virtuous, recorded deeds)? is the message...

Ross
 

Huck

Ross G Caldwell said:
Hi Huck,

here's where my memory screwed up. Panormita says in the description
http://www.bibliotecaitaliana.it/xtf/view?docId=bibit001050/bibit001050.xml

that Fortune (here conflated with Opportunity, as we later know her, with a forelock and bald behind) was followed by "six" virtues, and then proceeds to list *seven* - Hope, Faith, Charity, Fortitude, Temperance, Prudence, followed later by Justice, to emphasize her importance.

Caesar comes next, and mentions the seven virtues.

Later on, a giant tower comes surrounded by four further virtues, Magnanimitas, Constantia, Clementia, and Liberalitas.



Fame, by that name, is nowhere to be found (at least in my quick reading), but Julius Caesar (as mentioned by Burckhardt), who comes between Fortune with the virtues and the tower with four others, clearly symbolizes Fame (he is standing on a rotaing globe and declares "Behold both this changeful world and everything else unsure, except virtue." (Ecce et mundus volubilis et praeter virtutem omnia incerta).

Ubi sunt qui ante nos fuerunt (except for virtuous, recorded deeds)? is the message...

Ross

I've here a German description: Napolitans, Florentians and Katalans made the Trionfo.

Naples-part: The first part are 20 Napoletan patriziens with a baldachin and below it Alfonso himself on a chariot.

Florence part: youthful horsemen, which make some tricks with their spears, a a chariot with a Fortuna and seven (or six) virtues on horses. At the foot of Fortuna a Genius, showing, that luck can easily disappear.
As last virtue came a Justice on a chariot (likely explaining this problem with 6 or 7 virtues). And 12 Prophets. Then a lot of horses disguised as foreign nations or famous men, finally above a turning world-globe Julius Caesar, who explained to Alfonso the different allegories.

Katalan part: various Katalans on pseudo-horses, occupied with a battle-imitation with some Turks. Finally a gigantical Tower with an angel with sword protecting the door of the tower. Above 4 virtues, which sing songs for Alfonso.

Burckhardt (other source):
"Alfonso the Great, on his entrance into Naples (1443), declined the wreath of laurel, which Napoleon did not disdain to wear at his coronation in Notre-Dame. For the rest, Alfonso's procession, which passed by a breach in the wall through the city to the cathedral, was a strange mixture of antique, allegorical, and purely comic elements. The car, drawn by four white horses, on which he sat enthroned, was lofty and covered with gilding; twenty patricians carried the poles of the canopy of cloth of gold which shaded his head. The part of the procession which the Florentines then present in Naples had undertaken was composed of elegant young cavaliers, skillfully brandishing their lances, of a chariot with the figure of Fortune, and of seven Virtues on horseback. The goddess herself, in accordance with the inexorable logic of allegory to which even the painters at that time conformed, wore hair only on the front part of her head, while the back part was bald, and the genius who sat on the lower steps of the car, and who symbolized the fugitive character of fortune, had his feet immersed in a basin of water Then followed, equipped by the same Florentines, a troop of horsemen in the costumes of various nations, dressed as foreign princes and nobles, and then, crowned with laurel and standing above a revolving globe, a Julius Caesar, who explained to the king in Italian verse the meaning of the allegories, and then took his place in the procession. Sixty Florentines, all in purple and scarlet, closed this splendid display of what their home could achieve. Then a band of Catalans advanced on foot, with lay figures of horses fastened on to them before and behind, and engaged in a mock combat with a body of Turks, as though in derision of the Florentine sentimentalism. Last of all came a gigantic tower, the door guarded by an angel with a drawn sword; on it stood four Virtues, who each addressed the king with a song. The rest of the show had nothing specially characteristic about it. "

You're right, Fame is in this event only indirectly involved (by Caesar, but this might be refered to world also).

Fame is perhaps more involved in the event of 1423, when the Catalan part had a gigantcal chariot with artificial elephant, on top a castle of heaven with a chor of angels. Between the feets of the elephant a Magician, who is accompanied by 30 noble-men, disguised as Sarazens. They play a sorcery scene, with much noise and likely with fire-tricks.
They are attacked by two Napolese chariots with firework and exploding bombs, and accompanying persons, disguised as devils.

The Elephant symbolizes Fame ... but again this is weak.

Well, actually also the Aiolos appearance in the 1424/25 Michelino deck is a weak fame. Perhaps it's so, that the iconographical representation still wasn't found till 1440.

The Naples connection to Fame is clear with the Trionfi of 1475 (marriage Pesaro) and 1492, both called "Triumph of Fame". Another event from 1476 shows the "Trionfi of Petrarca", naturally also including Fame.

Back to the poem:

Quanto tuo maiestà ogn'uom prevale,
la tua alma Lucrezia in fama avanza
ogni altra donna mai fin qui famosa
d'incredibil biltate e di costanza
e di sublime ingegno naturale,
dove carità, fede e speme posa,
stella radïosa
d'onestate e clemenza,
fior di magnificenza,
prudente, giusta, temperata e forte,
qual viva sempre fu dopo la morte
ne' gentil almi di chi ci succede,
se la matura sorte
non niega a' versi miei meritar fede.

I see three of your 4 termini on the final chariot directly given in this short piece: clemenza, magnificenza, costanze ... Liberalitas I do miss, but I see Fama in the poem. Liberalitas = Fame?

In the begin of the poem also Julius Caesar is given together with other famous men (the description of the real Trionfo is open, which other famous men were given, actually also the Greek gods might have been famous men then).

When Famawas associated with books, as you've observed elsewhere, the way from Fama to Libertas is possibly not too far.

Stella radiosa .... the Angel? Who is this Lucrezia inside this context. The normal Roman Lucrezia?
 

Rosanne

From a translated (1878) book by Jacob Burckhardt called 'The Cilvilisation of the Renaissance in Italy. The Swiss historian Jacob Christoph Burckhardt (1818-1897) was a philosophical historian whose books dealt with cultural and artistic history and whose lectures examined the forces that had shaped European history.


That at a later time the Florentines used to travel through Italy as directors of festivals (festaiuoli), shows that the art was early perfected at home......<>
..Alfonso the Great, on his entrance into Naples (1443), declined the wreath of laurel, which Napoleon did not disdain to wear at his coronation in Notre-Dame. For the rest, Alfonso's procession, which passed by a breach in the wall through the city to the cathedral, was a strange mixture of antique, allegorical, and purely comic elements. The car, drawn by four white horses, on which he sat enthroned, was lofty and covered with gilding; twenty patricians carried the poles of the canopy of cloth of gold which shaded his head. The part of the procession which the Florentines then present in Naples had undertaken was composed of elegant young cavaliers, skillfully brandishing their lances, of a chariot with the figure of Fortune, and of seven Virtues on horseback. The goddess herself, in accordance with the inexorable logic of allegory to which even the painters at that time conformed, wore hair only on the front part of her head, while the back part was bald, and the genius who sat on the lower steps of the car, and who symbolized the fugitive character of fortune, had his feet immersed in a basin of water Then followed, equipped by the same Florentines, a troop of horsemen in the costumes of various nations, dressed as foreign princes and nobles, and then, crowned with laurel and standing above a revolving globe, a Julius Caesar, who explained to the king in Italian verse the meaning of the allegories, and then took his place in the procession. Sixty Florentines, all in purple and scarlet, closed this splendid display of what their home could achieve. Then a band of Catalans advanced on foot, with lay figures of horses fastened on to them before and behind, and engaged in a mock combat with a body of Turks, as though in derision of the Florentine sentimentalism. Last of all came a gigantic tower, the door guarded by an angel with a drawn sword; on it stood four Virtues, who each addressed the king with a song. The rest of the show had nothing specially characteristic about it.
Seems that in 1443 this was an already practised event of Fortune on a Chariot.
~Rosanne
 

Huck

Huck said:
Stella radiosa .... the Angel? Who is this Lucrezia inside this context. The normal Roman Lucrezia?

The Lucrezia riddle in the poem solves with this:

"Alfonso had been in love with a woman of noble family named Lucrezia d'Alagno, who served as a de facto queen at the Neapolitan court as well as an inspiring muse." wikipedia.
 

Huck

Petrarca enthusiam

Just on a sidepath I found this, somehow a piece of evidence for Petrarca-enthusiasm in the relevant time (enthusiasm about new iconographical type "Fame" should be likely regarded as detail of the Petrarca-enthusiasm.

Macchiavelli, story of Stefano Porcaro

The pontiff did not interfere in these affairs further than to endeavor to bring the parties to a mutual accommodation; but while he refrained from external wars he incurred the danger of more serious troubles at home. Stefano Porcari was a Roman citizen, equally distinguished for nobility of birth and extent of learning, but still more by the excellence of his character. Like all who are in pursuit of glory, he resolved either to perform or to attempt something worthy of memory, and thought he could not do better than deliver his country from the hands of the prelates, and restore the ancient form of government; hoping, in the event of success, to be considered a new founder or second father of the city. The dissolute manners of the priesthood, and the discontent of the Roman barons and people, encouraged him to look for a happy termination of his enterprise; but he derived his greatest confidence from those verses of Petrarch in the canzone which begins, "Spirto gentil che quelle membra reggi," where he says,—

"Sopra il Monte Tarpejo canzon vedra, Un cavalier, ch' Italia tutta onora, Pensoso piu d'altrui, che di se stesso."

Stefano, believing poets are sometimes endowed with a divine and prophetic spirit, thought the event must take place which Petrarch in this canzone seemed to foretell, and that he was destined to effect the glorious task; considering himself in learning, eloquence, friends, and influence, superior to any other citizen of Rome. Having taken these impressions, he had not sufficient prudence to avoid discovering his design by his discourse, demeanor, and mode of living; so that the pope becoming acquainted with it, in order to prevent the commission of some rash act, banished him to Bologna and charged the governor of the city to compel his appearance before him once every day. Stefano was not daunted by this first check, but with even greater earnestness prosecuted his undertaking, and, by such means as were available, more cautiously corresponded with his friends, and often went and returned from Rome with such celerity as to be in time to present himself before the governor within the limit allowed for his appearance. Having acquired a sufficient number of partisans, he determined to make the attempt without further delay, and arranged with his friends at Rome to provide an evening banquet, to which all the conspirators were invited, with orders that each should bring with him his most trust-worthy friends, and himself promised to be with him before the entertainment was served. Everything was done according to this orders, and Stefano Porcari arrived at the place appointed. Supper being brought in, he entered the apartment dressed in cloth of gold, with rich ornaments about his neck, to give him a dignified appearance and commanding aspect. Having embraced the company, he delivered a long oration to dispose their minds to the glorious undertaking. He then arranged the measures to be adopted, ordering that one part of them should, on the following morning, take possession of the pontiff's palace, and that the other should call the people of Rome to arms. The affair came to the knowledge of the pope the same night, some say by treachery among the conspirators, and others that he knew of Porcari's presence at Rome. Be this as it may, on the night of the supper Stefano, and the greater part of his associates, were arrested, and afterward expiated their crime by death. Thus ended his enterprise; and though some may applaud his intentions, he must stand charged with deficiency of understanding; for such undertakings, though possessing some slight appearance of glory, are almost always attended with ruin.

This should have happened 1453 and it was a major event in this year.

Another sign of Petrarca enthusiasm is the series of 9 frescoes with famous persons, likely a Florentine development of the German-French 9-heroes-scheme:

9petrarc.jpg


It's one of 9 figures and the whole scheme had 3 poets, 3 Florentine militarical heroes and 3 famous women :

Petrarca - Dante - Boccaccio
Niccolo Acciaiuoli - Farinata degli Uberti - Pippo Spano
Tamiris - Esther - Cumean Sybil

"Andrea del Castagno was commissioned the Famous Men and Women cycle of the villa Carducci in Legnaia no later than June 1449, when Filippo Carducci, the owner of the villa and most probably the one who commissioned the frescoes, died. The frescoes were finished before the house was sold in October 1451."

More pictures
http://www.wga.hu/frames-e.html?/html/a/andrea/castagno/2_famous/index.html

This Andrea del Castagno, who has with his often used "one-person-per-picture-or-frame-style" somehow a simlarity to the ways, in which Tarot cards are painted, has an interesting life story and a very specific feature, which should raise the eye-brows of Tarot history researchers and making them start to think.

First: the life story of him is totally confused - what's true or not, is hidden.

Likely he died 1457, but some have him living till ca. 1480.

The remarkable thing is, that he had a nick-name: Andreino degli Impiccati ("Little Andrea of the Hanged Men") and these hanged men war hanged by their heels. Very different explanations are given as reason, why he had this nick-name.

Let's try another explanation: Perhaps Andrea Castagno had something to do with the invention of the figure in Hanging Man in the Tarot game?

... :) ... I leave it to you to discover the different versions of life of this man.
 

Ross G Caldwell

Hi Huck,

I haven't looked too much at Andrea del Castagno... my take is that he was called that because he made so many - or some (in)famous - "shame paintings" (commissions, of course). But I'll look at him some more.

Huck said:
Just on a sidepath I found this, somehow a piece of evidence for Petrarca-enthusiasm in the relevant time (enthusiasm about new iconographical type "Fame" should be likely regarded as detail of the Petrarca-enthusiasm.

I don't know we need a lot more evidence for the beginning of the Petrarchan Trionfi enthusiasm. From what I can tell, it must have started in Florence, around 1440.

I just looked through the Este library for 1436 and 1467, and they have 8 or 9 Petrarch works, but not the Trionfi.

Visconti is the same, with 1426 and 1459 full of Petrarch, but not the Trionfi. Only in 1469 does Galeazzo Maria' inventory notice the Trionfi as a volume.

It seems that Florence is the main place to look, in these decades, for literary and iconographical evidence of the popularity of the Trionfi.

Ross
 

Huck

I would say, that the council 1438/39 Ferrara/Florence - naturally accompanied by an increased manuscript-duplication process - generated people, who had for some time a concrete occupation in the "publishing business" - as small as it was in this time, it was increased against the state before. And Pietro made the poetical competion 1440 and Cosimo opened a public library in Florence 1444. And 1447 there was a pope with a lot of interest in book-production. He builded the stock for the Vatican library. And paid astronomical prizes for some progress in the process.

This all are escalating steps. It grows (or "explodes" to more and more) in short time. And those people, who were active in Ferrara/Florence in 1438/39 asked after it: "What next" and that was the motor of the development. As the process of 1438/39 mostly were "copy from old to new" or "translate from Greek to Latin" after the council such questions like "who were the greatest writers in the last 100 years" were natural and the answer "that was Petrarca" was not far.

So "around 1440" looks as a good estimation.

Perhaps the figure of Fame hadn't found an iconography till then, but the new interest in the "Trionfi" of Petrarca formed an interest to paint Fame. Visconti's Fame in the Cary-Yale is quite different from Florence solutions ...

... but it might have been the first ... did we till now meet another Fame before 1441?