While it's true that the Classical is a reproduction of the same deck as the Soprafino, to me there are miles of difference between them.
Meneghello's version feels like a genuine antique... from the unlaminated cardstock (much more durable than you'd think; just don't spill anything on it), the handmade box with a wax seal, the cream-coloured cardstock, and the simple pattern on the backs which seems very traditional.
The Lo Scarabeo version seems much more modern.. Standard semi-glossy stock, the backs are a monochromatic image of the star card, flipped so it's reversible. There are noticible borders on the front, with multilingual titles, including some (strange, imho) keywords for each card, running down one side.
There is a difference in price, but to me, it's well worth the money for such a treasure of a deck.