Let's Marseilles Forum....

TemperanceAngel · 08-02-2005

We used to have great discussions in that Forum and I wonder why we are only allowed to post readings and not discussions as well?

It seems I would then have to post a thread relating to the Let's Marseilles Forum in Talking Tarot or Using Tarot Cards.

I thought when the Forum was set up it was to put all the readings and discussion in one area?

Maybe I am confused, wouldn't surprise me

So my suggestion is this: can we also have discussions about the cards/readings etc in the same Forum? It makes it a much better way to learn. The Forum is feeling very stagnant at the moment.....

Rusty Neon · 08-02-2005

http://www.tarotforum.net/showthread.php?t=35396

TemperanceAngel · 08-02-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rusty Neon

http://www.tarotforum.net/showthread.php?t=35396

Thanks Rusty I have read that, that is why I made the suggestion as it seems that there is not the interaction in the Forum like there used to be.

I for one really enjoyed the discussions about the readings etc.

Fulgour · 08-02-2005

Is there an Australian equivalent for Jerry Springer,
or someone as shamelessly irresponsible as Geraldo?

What was happening before in the name of discussion
was little more than personality promotion for ratings.

Many have chosen to avoid "Let's Marseille!" because
instead of focusing on readings, it got to be rantings.

Fulgour · 09-02-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by TemperanceAngel

I for one really enjoyed the discussions about the readings etc.

It may be here that when a reading is posted
there ought to be a clear statement that all
comments are welcome, by anyone from the
general Aeclectic Tarot Forum Community.

Rusty Neon · 09-02-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by TemperanceAngel

It seems I would then have to post a thread relating to the Let's Marseilles Forum in Talking Tarot or Using Tarot Cards.

... or oftentimes in the Marseilles and Other Early Tarot Decks forum, which is the study forum specified by Solandia for the Marseilles deck. As I understand it, the Let's Marseilles subforum was intended for reading circles using the Marseilles deck under the Let's Marseilles caption and wasn't intended to supplant this general role of the Marseilles and Other Early Tarot Decks forum. The posting of discussion threads in the Marseilles and Other Early Tarot Decks forum encourages participation and input by the larger ATF community interested in the Marseilles deck and helps to ensure a wider breadth and range of responses.

Not everyone in the larger ATF TdM community always has the time and energy to read through posted readings to look for such discussions.

Just my two pence.

TemperanceAngel · 09-02-2005

Good points Rusty, I hear you and agree with you somewhat. But would still love to discuss pertaining to the Let's Marseilles in that Forum. I feel that the Marseilles etc. Forums discussions are very different in nature to the Let's Marseilles Forum.

On saying all this, maybe it would be a great idea to move the Let's Marseilles into the Historical area where it could connect with the Marseilles discussions there?

Just a thought

Thanks for your comments Rusty and Fulgour, it's always interesting to hear others peoples thoughts and ideas.

Fulgour · 10-02-2005

Quote:

Originally Posted by TemperanceAngel

On saying all this, maybe it would be a great idea to move the Let's Marseilles into the Historical area where it could connect with the Marseilles discussions there?

Thanks, TemperanceAngel. Let us know, please?

?) Aeclectic Tarot Forum - Historical Research
http://www.tarotforum.net/forumdisplay.php?f=78

OR

?) Aeclectic Tarot Forum - Crystals & Herbs
http://www.tarotforum.net/forumdisplay.php?f=49

TemperanceAngel · 10-02-2005

Sorry Fulgour, I think I don't understand your post, can you please explain?
Re: crystals and herbs?

Back to the thread: when I started this I was obviously rambling, but posted here to hear others thoughts....which have been interesting so far.

As Let's Marseilles! Forum is new and there is a lot of learning going on there it would be great to discuss such things in the same forum....I think that, that is an important part of any learning.

I am doing a double degree and in our lectures thay are open to questions and discussions. It's a great way to learn and keep the brain stimulated. Otherwise we would sit there for three hours and not be able to absorb much at all.

I hope that makes sense and connects in with what I am trying to get across about the Let's Marseilles! Forum? It is the Suggestions area after all, I think it is also a great brain storming area too

Moongold · 10-02-2005

One of the most practical ways to learn is by doing. People learn to read by actually doing readings. I really like that way of learning. It has always been quite difficult to get others involved in commenting on other people's readings, even non-Marseille readings. It simply seems to be something that people prefer not to do.

TA, I think there are plenty of opportunities for people to get creative learning opportunities in the Marseilles. Each forum is just a click away.

To actually get readings going all the time would be the ideal. Even just once a month to have a Marseille reading experience of some kind occurring would be good. And that is up to the energy of individuals. I have just started something different in Let's Marseille if people would like to have a look.

Some of the best learning for me has occurred in the discussion threads which JMD commenced. VII Chariot......How may it be read? They are simply great but I'm a bit out of energy at the moment. The Marseilles requires quite a lot of reflection and meditation. I do plan to go back. It doesn't hurt to pose some challenging questions to brighten things up a bit in those threads.

The sort of thing I think you are suggesting, TA, is more like a study thread but from memory that idea was knocked on the head in the early stages of the discussion about this.

My own opinion is that whatever is commenced will require ongoing commitment and energy from those involved. Maria has done a fantastic job in organizing the energy readings. Fulgour is always there with sharp and often funny contributions. We just need a few more.

Even a study group will die without this special commitment. There is much material about the Marseille available on Aeclectic. You can spend hours ploughing through it all.

I would like to see some Marseilles readers take the plunge and offer readings to other Aeclectic members through the Let's Marseile Forum. That would spice things up a bit. TA - you are a great reader. Why not start doing that? I would take you up on such an offer immediately.

TemperanceAngel Citizen Join Date: 21 Oct 2003 Location: A Parallel Universe Posts: 5,039	Let's Marseilles Forum.... We used to have great discussions in that Forum and I wonder why we are only allowed to post readings and not discussions as well? It seems I would then have to post a thread relating to the Let's Marseilles Forum in Talking Tarot or Using Tarot Cards. I thought when the Forum was set up it was to put all the readings and discussion in one area? Maybe I am confused, wouldn't surprise me So my suggestion is this: can we also have discussions about the cards/readings etc in the same Forum? It makes it a much better way to learn. The Forum is feeling very stagnant at the moment.....

08-02-2005	Ask a Professional Tarot Reader Top #1

Rusty Neon Citizen Join Date: 12 Mar 2003 Location: Land of Snow and Ice (O Canada) Posts: 4,843	Let's Marseilles Forum.... http://www.tarotforum.net/showthread.php?t=35396

08-02-2005	Ask a Professional Tarot Reader Top #2

Fulgour Citizen Join Date: 10 Jun 2004 Location: slumbrin in the windrows of the hours... Posts: 7,828	Cultural bias Is there an Australian equivalent for Jerry Springer, or someone as shamelessly irresponsible as Geraldo? What was happening before in the name of discussion was little more than personality promotion for ratings. Many have chosen to avoid "Let's Marseille!" because instead of focusing on readings, it got to be rantings.

08-02-2005	Ask a Professional Tarot Reader Top #4

Moongold Citizen Join Date: 08 Jun 2002 Posts: 7,723	Some thoughts ...... One of the most practical ways to learn is by doing. People learn to read by actually doing readings. I really like that way of learning. It has always been quite difficult to get others involved in commenting on other people's readings, even non-Marseille readings. It simply seems to be something that people prefer not to do. TA, I think there are plenty of opportunities for people to get creative learning opportunities in the Marseilles. Each forum is just a click away. To actually get readings going all the time would be the ideal. Even just once a month to have a Marseille reading experience of some kind occurring would be good. And that is up to the energy of individuals. I have just started something different in Let's Marseille if people would like to have a look. Some of the best learning for me has occurred in the discussion threads which JMD commenced. VII Chariot......How may it be read? They are simply great but I'm a bit out of energy at the moment. The Marseilles requires quite a lot of reflection and meditation. I do plan to go back. It doesn't hurt to pose some challenging questions to brighten things up a bit in those threads. The sort of thing I think you are suggesting, TA, is more like a study thread but from memory that idea was knocked on the head in the early stages of the discussion about this. My own opinion is that whatever is commenced will require ongoing commitment and energy from those involved. Maria has done a fantastic job in organizing the energy readings. Fulgour is always there with sharp and often funny contributions. We just need a few more. Even a study group will die without this special commitment. There is much material about the Marseille available on Aeclectic. You can spend hours ploughing through it all. I would like to see some Marseilles readers take the plunge and offer readings to other Aeclectic members through the Let's Marseile Forum. That would spice things up a bit. TA - you are a great reader. Why not start doing that? I would take you up on such an offer immediately. Last edited by Moongold; 10-02-2005 at 06:35.

10-02-2005	Ask a Professional Tarot Reader Top #10

TemperanceAngel Citizen Join Date: 21 Oct 2003 Location: A Parallel Universe Posts: 5,039	Good points Rusty, I hear you and agree with you somewhat. But would still love to discuss pertaining to the Let's Marseilles in that Forum. I feel that the Marseilles etc. Forums discussions are very different in nature to the Let's Marseilles Forum. On saying all this, maybe it would be a great idea to move the Let's Marseilles into the Historical area where it could connect with the Marseilles discussions there? Just a thought Thanks for your comments Rusty and Fulgour, it's always interesting to hear others peoples thoughts and ideas.

09-02-2005	Ask a Professional Tarot Reader Top #7

Ads by Google via Google Adsense
	#ADS