Red Emma
When I listed the medications, OTC stuff and herbs, take for a doctor in ER last week, she was quite scornful of St. Johns Wort.
I had come into ER because my heart had started dancing to its own syncopated beat, which the staff was trying to understand. I included St. Johns Wort for depression among the drugs and OTC vitamins and minerals I listed.
Depression is one of the banes of my life, and St Johns has kept it under control for several years. She (the m.d.) skirted being scornful, sarcastic, etc about it. She did say that it's of very little use, I'd be better off without it.
After three days of 'observation', they observed that my heart is strong and healthy. It could use a whole lot less stress than it's been dealing with of late. I'm home, and my husband and I are identifying the stresses, and learning how to deal with them. At the end of three days I feel much better.
BUT! I do intend to follow up this contretemps over a very good herb-depression medicine. First I need to find out if there's some new research questioning its eficacy, which I haven't heard about. Then check the various "Physicians Desk Reference" for Herbal Medicines to see if they've withdrawn their support for it.
When I've gathered all the info, I plan to broach the administrators of my HMO and find out what the hell is going on.
Since it's my heart at stake, and I am 81, I will follow the m.d.'s directives unil I get all the backup I need. I strongly suspect that SJW will be back in my medicine cabinet before long.
Blessings
I had come into ER because my heart had started dancing to its own syncopated beat, which the staff was trying to understand. I included St. Johns Wort for depression among the drugs and OTC vitamins and minerals I listed.
Depression is one of the banes of my life, and St Johns has kept it under control for several years. She (the m.d.) skirted being scornful, sarcastic, etc about it. She did say that it's of very little use, I'd be better off without it.
After three days of 'observation', they observed that my heart is strong and healthy. It could use a whole lot less stress than it's been dealing with of late. I'm home, and my husband and I are identifying the stresses, and learning how to deal with them. At the end of three days I feel much better.
BUT! I do intend to follow up this contretemps over a very good herb-depression medicine. First I need to find out if there's some new research questioning its eficacy, which I haven't heard about. Then check the various "Physicians Desk Reference" for Herbal Medicines to see if they've withdrawn their support for it.
When I've gathered all the info, I plan to broach the administrators of my HMO and find out what the hell is going on.
Since it's my heart at stake, and I am 81, I will follow the m.d.'s directives unil I get all the backup I need. I strongly suspect that SJW will be back in my medicine cabinet before long.
Blessings