Tarot Forum    

Fixed vs. Adaptable meanings when reading cards?

> Tarot Forum > Tarot > Using Tarot Cards

DJP  DJP is offline
Join Date: 26 Apr 2017
Location: South Africa
Posts: 74
Fixed vs. Adaptable meanings when reading cards?


I'd be really interested in getting people's good natured thoughts on whether or not they use fixed (traditional) meanings when interpreting a card or if they take a more adaptable approach .... I'd also like to know why they feel it's the best approach for them.

Personally, I see the sense in both.

On the one hand, if you believe that cards appear for a specific reason in relation to a question (as opposed to the ink-blot effect), then I don't see why they couldn't have shown up to trigger an idiosyncratic interpretation or association in the reader.

Conversely, it could be said that traditional meanings have centuries (?) of experience and evolution (natural selection, even) behind them....

I'd love to get some perspectives on this.


P.S. Please, I'm definitely NOT asking for opinions on which method is superior!
P.P.S. I may be a little slow for a day or two in posting replies.
Top   #1
Barleywine's Avatar
Barleywine  Barleywine is offline
Elder Jabberwock
Join Date: 10 Jun 2011
Location: Where the wild things are
Posts: 9,055

I believe both are relevant to varying degrees at any time, and my own approach is a synthesis of the two. The traditional meanings are the bedrock that most of us learned as beginner's, but they're mainly "training wheels" that we grow beyond as we gain confidence from our own experience. The basics are still there in our memory, in the background and available to be tapped when inspiration fails, but they aren't usually the first thing that comes to mind when I see a particular card in a spread. On the other hand, I feel the same way about the traditional images on the cards. The folklore that has grown up around those is equally optional when reading the cards; sometimes an impression comes from a story-telling trope (metaphor, analogy, allegory, etc) or cultural reference that speaks right to the essence of the card with no historical or folkloric basis whatsoever. The best of these I mentally file with my accumulated knowledge base, and after a while they become part of my personal tradition.
Top   #2
IndigoWaves  IndigoWaves is offline
Join Date: 10 Feb 2008
Location: .
Posts: 1,424

I'm pretty well fixed on RWS meanings, myself, as they seem to be utilized most often by others and have tended to jibe with my interpretations, accuracy-wise... But sometimes an intuitive card visual will come across that overrides "typical" meanings... And it's important to follow such leads when they occur, I've found, or an important detail can be missed/misread.
Top   #3
DJP  DJP is offline
Join Date: 26 Apr 2017
Location: South Africa
Posts: 74

Hi Barleywine & IndigoWaves,

I'm definitely still at the stage of learning the ins and outs of the traditional meanings. But I must say, my best results reading wise so far have come about when a creative 'leap of imagination' has been involved.

Still, traditional meanings are surely a helpful test, ensuring beginners like myself don't float off into internal fantasy land! As the poet Wendell Berry once wrote, art must always be tested against reality.

P.S. Barleywine, "Personal tradition" is a beautiful phrase.
Top   #4
Barleywine's Avatar
Barleywine  Barleywine is offline
Elder Jabberwock
Join Date: 10 Jun 2011
Location: Where the wild things are
Posts: 9,055

Originally Posted by DJP View Post
But I must say, my best results reading wise so far have come about when a creative 'leap of imagination' has been involved.
Still true for me as well. I consider it part of continuing to learn something new with every reading I perform, even after many years of doing it.
Top   #5

greatdane  greatdane is offline
The Lone Crone
Join Date: 16 Mar 2010
Location: ---------
Posts: 20,276

Whatever meanings I have for a card are the jump off point, so I would say both.

There are various meanings a card can have for me based on the question and, from there, intuition, my own thoughts, take over.

I would say depends where a card is in a spread, except I do one card, one question, so it is more the question, what meanings I generally have given the card, and then my intuition.
Top   #6
stclair's Avatar
stclair  stclair is offline
Join Date: 04 Apr 2017
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 21

Chiming in to agree with Indigowaves and Barleywine. The 'textbook' meanings are the springboard/lynchpin, and I think it's important to have at least a rudimentary understanding of the symbolism and origins of whatever system you're using. But as you learn and practice, certain cards may come to mean specific things to you, or come up as indicators of particular situations, that will be your own lexicon. And intuition can flash unusual, weirdo things from a card that may not be a traditional connection but relevant nonetheless! So yes, a blending of both.
Top   #7
headincloud's Avatar
headincloud  headincloud is offline
Join Date: 12 Feb 2014
Location: Feet on the ground
Posts: 2,147

I use both I guess but not in the manner described above, I stick to traditional meanings and the symbolism serves to jolt my memory of all the meanings I've pinned on a card. I don't deviate because I don't see there's any need to, every possibility is covered therein so why confuse things, anything I pin on a card myself would be doubling up somewhere along the line as the traditional tarot is a complete system in itself.

The intuitive part for me is deciding which rote meanings apply to which cards in any given combination, aspects of the card that are being highlighted by the surrounding spread,the dynamics between cards.
Top   #8
obeygravity's Avatar
obeygravity  obeygravity is offline
Join Date: 22 Nov 2008
Location: Project Mayhem
Posts: 11,461

I read pretty much only intuitively/visually now which means sometimes the message I get when I read the cards can deviate a teeny tiny bit from the traditional meaning. I think a lot of that is also because I have so many varied decks that don't inherently follow RWS imagery that my personal understanding and relationship to each card has shifted a great deal from when I first started reading. I still keep the base definitions in mind since, regardless of the deck, it's still a certain level of influence. But I enjoy digging deeper into each card and enjoy the process of learning about how other people relate to each card as well.
Top   #9
gregory's Avatar
gregory  gregory is offline
Cat on a cold stone roof
Join Date: 01 Jan 2004
Location: The world of the things that could have been.
Posts: 72,249

If textbook meanings did it all, there'd be no need for readers; you (generic) could just draw the cards and look them up. That doesn't do it, though - so I think you have to allow that there are extra nuances, that meanings are adaptable.
Top   #10



Elsewhere on the Tarot Forum
Popular Tarot Boards
· Using Tarot Cards
· Talking Tarot
· Tarot Spreads
· Tarot Decks
· Tarot Readings
· Reading Exchange
Special Interest Boards
· Astrology
· Crystals & Herbs
· Divination
· Lenormand
· Rider-Waite-Smith
· Spirituality

Popular Tarot Threads
· Pet Peeves
· Timing of cards
· Interesting tarot pairs
· The Moon as how someone feels
· The World as feelings

More Tarot Threads
· Cards for certain events
· Tarot meanings for health
· List of Tarot Questions
· Can Tarot be Dangerous?
· List of Tarot Myths

Elsewhere on Aeclectic Tarot
· 2000+ Tarot Reviews
· Free Tarot Readings
· Tarot Card Meanings

Copyright © 1996 - 2022 Aeclectic Tarot. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy. Contact us. About us. Advertise with us.