canid said:
what do most readers generally do regarding reversals/elementals? Is it a personal preference of the reader's, one or the other, a combination, or is it entirely intuitive which method you use?
Mind you, I'm just now dabbling a bit with EDs (usually with specific decks, like my New Orleans Voodoo Tarot or the Thoth), but from what I understand, reversals aren't usually used with EDs. Instead, a card that may be considered "reversed" in a deck that addresses reversals would, instead, be "ill-dignified"--meaning, a card is of an element that is not friendly with the element(s) near it.
For example: if you have a fire card next to a water card (say...a Wands card next to a Cups card), that fire card would be ill-dignified to the water card...fire can be put out by water. Likewise, a fire card (Wands) next to an air card (Swords, if you read swords as air--but that's a whole 'nother issue
) is considered "well-dignified" or, in a traditional deck, "upright", since air and fire like each other (air feeds fire).
(but then, as you get deeper into EDs, there's the whole "fire of water" and "air of earth" type of things going on, and my mind is just not there yet.
).
Maybe those who read with EDs on a regular basis can chime in with their more extensive knowledge.
Just my $.02.
T.