A well-phrased question is essential, but I would agree that asking the same question - even twice - produces gobbledegook. Even the most obtuse reading will yield results if looked at properly.
To give the monk the benefit of the doubt that
might have been what he meant, BUT the advice is the same: anything that comes from the ego self is bad, and he sounds like he is giving in to the ego's siren call to abuse and flaunt his powers rather than helping you to open up your own.
In this case it sounds like the monk wanted to keep you dependent on him for readings. How do you suppose he made a go of fortune-telling with tarot if you could only use it twice a week? With tarot and ability go responsibility: there are people in the world who have such uncanny abilities for manipulation of others that they must have access to powers like this and abuse it. A good tarot reader or spiritualist in any discipline of divination, magick, healing or mediumship will help and encourage you to empower yourself, not shroud talents in mystery and old-wives'-tales. I don't read for myself every day (all I do usually is pull a card for the day unless I have come to a real impasse, but I don't bother every single day), but if I get frustrated and cast the cards again for the same issue (such as looking for the same object), it is unintelligible nonsense, or worse - some decks like the Morgan-Greer go out of their way to throw up nasty cards like the Devil, usually a sign they are annoyed that you are giving in to your ego and questioning their wisdom. Even if I make a mistake in the spread or leave a card or two in the box, that counts, since even mistakes are made for a reason.
SunChariot said:
That being said I don't think there is anything you can do just by reading for a person that could harm them. Unless you give them some bad advice. By the readings themselves are not harmful. Maybe depending on whom or what you are trying to contact to get answers from. Personally I am asking of G-d, who is not in the business of harming people. Others ask the universe, same thing...Answers coming from a good kind place will not harm anyone.
PS I did get scared that I foretold a death two weeks before it happened, and because I was in a kind of desperate state at the time I asked for a prediction (it wasn't while using tarot, but I would have got the answer through whichever method of divination I tried), I thought I might have caused it. However someone the other day put my mind at rest by saying that "if X's life path is that he will pass over on XX/YY, then there is nothing you can do to stop him, even if you foretell his death beforehand, even if you let him know". I couldn't tell anyone because I only saw "a death" not "X's death", and humans seem to have an inbuilt capacity for ignoring premonitions of death, unless they themselves have a funny feeling - read the story of Cassandra or "Julius Caesar" and you'll see why.
For example, say you give good advice - don't go to that party, you'll drink too much and coming home you'll have a fatal accident. The person decides not to go. Then his mate calls him up. C'mon, let's go, I'll drive, it's OK, I'm not going to have anything to drink. So they go. The guy feels it's OK to get drunk. His mate stays sober. Then on the way home a drunk driver (say middle-aged) comes speeding round the corner and crashes into the guy's car. The two boys and the drunk driver are all killed. The two boys themselves were not to blame for the accident, since they were more responsible than the third man (most kids I know are actually very good about not drink-driving nowadays).
All you can do - could have done - in this case is give the best of advice. Although you foretold his death, it was his free will to ignore your advice. Looking at it from a higher perspective, it was his life path to live fast, die young, perhaps as an example to others, perhaps as a test to his parents...read any book on spiritualism and you will discover some quite mindbending theories about the purpose of our spiritual existence.