Grizabella
My Green Witch is one of the most gentle to shuffle. I never had any problem at all with it even when it was brand new. It's been used a lot now and is wonderfully worn so that it shuffles like a dream. Over the years I've found that separate printings can be really different, even from the same publisher so maybe they switched to a different card stock after I got mine.
I hope you find a solution that will work for you. If nothing else works, at least I think it will soften up pretty quickly for you just from shuffling it a lot. It did for me.
I hope you find a solution that will work for you. If nothing else works, at least I think it will soften up pretty quickly for you just from shuffling it a lot. It did for me.