If it were the Queen/Cups, you'd be right. But the HPS isn't a Water element--though water is involved in that card. She's the Moon, remember? And an ill-dignified moon is crazy. The moon controls the tides, the sea, the very movement of all water whether there is air or not and one that's ill-dignified means that those waves are going nuts. All the lack of an Air card means is that things won't get blown down by wind.
And have you considered that the Queen/Pents might relate to the recent Earthquakes?
Earthquakes and big waves. Sounds pretty accurate to me.
Interesting !!
But how come I read so many things that state the High Priestess is water element?? *Ahh confused*
Hm, it wasn't really an earthquake here in NY - it was more of an aftershock , nothing too damaging, but I see what you mean.
I also got the page of pentacles in the same 3 card reading. My interpretation of these was that it (High Priestess=Hurricane Irene to me) wasn't going to be as damaging (queen of pentacles) as they state it would and it's going to diminish (Page of Pentacles). So far I'm keeping up w/ the news and she seems to be weakening...I'm keeping my fingers crossed =)
Edited to add: This is one of the sites that I read regularly and it states HP is water element
"Actually, both the Magician and the Fool are attributed to Air while the High Priestess is attributed to Water - and it might be perfectly okay to simply go with these connections.
On the other hand, these three Major cards are often seen as exceptions from the rule for the same reason as the Aces: their connection to Kether. If you look at the Tree of Life and watch the Paths coming from Kether, you will find that the Fool goes from Kether to Chokmah, the Magician from Kether to Binah and the High Priestess takes the long way down from Kether to Tiphareth.
It is hard to say which way is 'right' and as so often in Tarot there is a bit of both. I usually leave it up to the cards to decide - if for example the High Priestess is accompanied by another Water trump and several Minor Water cards I definitely won't ignore her Watery side." --- corax.com/tarot (I hope this isn't against the rules, if it is I will remove it)