Ah, something we can agree on.
The whole concept of fate/destiny works precisely because ordinary people, not armchair philosophers like ourselves, just get on with their daily business. Some have more impact on "global" events than others, but like the proverbial butterfly even the powerless can flap their wings sometimes and cause a hurricane. This chaos theory works like shuffling a tarot deck: if we just read with the deck straight out of the box, it wouldn't work. We have to shuffle the deck - paradoxically - to get any sense out of it.
As I said on another thread, every clairvoyant has to eat. The payment for food gives money to another. Say they go and spend the money they earn on a gun and rob a bank. The clairvoyant might be able to say that there is going to be a bank robbery somewhere or other, but they won't necessarily receive that information crystal clear, and be able to warn the bank in question, and if they do know, then the bank will say "hey, we're prepared, we have CCTV, and anyway, what do you know? if you're so psychic, why aren't you living in Barbados with a huge lottery win?". So the bank robbery happens - perhaps the police are waiting at another bank? perhaps the robber changes his mind which bank to rob? The robber doesn't really think about anything to do with psychic talent or tarot or whatever, he just fancies having a lot of money and the easiest way to do it is to hold up the NatWest. Therefore we have a gap between the
knowledge of what people are going to do, and those who just do it regardless. It's not like everyone has the time or energy or inclination, or even the belief, to sit around thinking about how time works. (If we did no-one would ever do anything and it would be just like reading with an unshuffled tarot deck).
It's not a very scientific theory, but it's a practical one. Marx said that philosophers needed to reconnect their theories with reality (one of the sanest things he ever said, as I am a true-blue Conservative when it comes to politics).
I read a book last night which brought this whole concept home to me very very starkly: a caption in a book about Nostradamus printed ten years or so ago which said, in other words: Although the latitude refers to New York, this doesn't mean that New York is necessarily where this destruction is going to take place. Other "new" cities are on the same latitude, such as the New Belgrade suburb in Serbia (!!!?!!!?). So any idea of New York being destroyed by fire can be ruled out.
Erm, quite. I
knew there was something odd when I went up the WTC in 1998. Even if Al-Qaeda got their ideas from the Independence Day movie trailers which showed the Chrysler building being blown up, I still shuddered when I saw those trailers at the same time as being in NYC. Saying I thought something was going to happen three years before it did is pushing it a bit, but nevertheless...
Not even Nostradamus could prevent 9/11. So ironically clairvoyance, future-telling and so on works
because people in their innocence assume it can't happen to them, or pay no attention to prophets of doom, or ridicule people like Nostradamus (an elderly friend I went to see last night told me an ancient Scottish seer said he saw ships sailing between Inverness and the Clyde. People thought he was barking mad at the time. Then they built a canal a few hundred years later.
Quad erat demonstrandum). There are times when fate decides that some incident can be averted, but in most cases, human arrogance, such as (in literature at least) that of Caesar and the Ides of March, overrides caution advised by seers. Babs' idea of the kid playing in the road sums it up completely. America was complacent about terrorism until 9/11, and Nostradamus evidently foresaw it. Once they had the shock, they took steps to remedy the situation - but not until 3000 odd people died in something that someone in 16th century France had seen in a bowl of water. Thus it is possible to see the future, and by extension, suggests that the future has - in a sense - already happened. If it is decreed in fate/destiny that the person pays heed to warnings of assassination or other calamities, then they will do so.