I made it down to the WiccaShoppe today. I am actually a little disappointed with it. While it does have a great selection of stones, herbs, incense, and jewelry, its selection of everything else leaves a lot to be desired. They had almost no books, and nearly all of what they did have was from Llewellyn. You can buy those anywhere!
The Tarot deck collection as pretty small, in my opinion. They had some boxed sets on the shelves. I remember Froud's Faeries Oracle, Soul Cards 1 and the Hanson-Roberts deck boxed with some book. There were one or two other sets, but I can't recall what they were. Nothing hard to find anyway.
Over in a case they have a collection of about 30 decks. Everything on the bottom self is first edition or out of print. They are all fairly mundane, yet cost and arm and a leg. There was a couple of Aquarian Tarot decks, a few old Thoths and Rider-Waites. Again, nothing hard-to-find.
As for the normally priced decks, they had an okay selection. Daughters of the Moon for C$48 (which you can buy from the author, with book, for US$25), Motherpeace, Nefertari's, Secrets Tarot, Hanson-Roberts, Caligostro. Again, nothing hard to find at all.
Really, I think they best selection, at an independent bookstore, would be the Omega Centre on Yorkville. It is easy to get to from Bay Station. (PM me if you'd like directions.) And the best overall selection, numbering at least 100, would be the World's Biggest Bookstore on Edward Street, near Eaton Centre. (Again, PM me for directions. I'm new to TO, but I will try the best I can to give good directions.) WiccaShoppe is great though, if you are looking for stones, herbs or incense. I finally got a piece of lapis!
Hopefully some day I will be able to check out some of those other stores on that site darwinia linked to.