Shamoness, I'll take a cloth if it comes with some basic instructions.
A star-shape is fine with me.
I've got a definite three items per person right now. The last treasure might just end up being distributed randomly.
I'm pretty sure I've got everyone's address now.
Since the like/don't like lists Celice and Kaleanna posted were very useful for me, I'll try to post one of my own.
Likes:
animals: especially big cats, wolves, foxes
fairies
figurines
Things I like, but probably already have somewhere
raw and polished stones
postage stamps
Things I like, and don't have yet:
antique keys (Skeleton key style)
glass marbles
sea glass
fossils
foreign/old coins
cameos
doll furniture (I like mini versions of real things)
Dislikes
Buttons (unless it is really unique)
seeds (probably wouldn't get to me anyway)
----
I'm just as willing to get modern/manufactured things as natural things. And since my theme is "textures" I wouldn't mind little bits of leather, velvet, silk etc.
Hope this helps!