Nathalie Hertz's Faerie Tarot
Why do I own this?
It seems I am doomed to deck regret when it comes to Nathalie Hertz, a talented artist who produces U.S. Games decks in themes that don't interest me whatsoever. Fantasy, vampires, fairies--no, no and no. My favorite decks include the Maat, the Navigators of the Mystic SEA, the Thoth, the Haindl...this should give you an idea of how far removed from my tastes such themed fantasy decks are.
Yet back when I was a fairly indiscriminate collector, I picked up her Fantastical Tarot when it came out (circa 1999-2000) because it was one of the only ones in the shop that I didn't yet own. I found the artwork accomplished but cold and leaden in expression, and I boxed it up with the rest of the collection.
Now here I am, 12-odd years later, with a Faerie Tarot I acquired sometime in the fall when I was on the ever-fruitless quest to acquire decks with strong autumn themes. Hertz's is one of the very few decks with strong seasonal demarcation (one season per suit), and her autumn and winter--the two seasons of interest to me-- are well-rendered.
But the fairies. The butterflies, the flowers, the toadstools, the rosy-cheeked gnomes. I can't take all this whimsy. I knew back when I was considering this deck that it would be a tough pill for me to swallow, but I reminded myself of the suit of Wands and cards like the forbidding, owl-y The Empress and took the plunge.
To be clear, I'm not an irredeemable curmudgeon. I try to be open-minded and am sometimes rewarded for it. For instance, The Tarot of the Sweet Twilight has a fair bit of whimsy and rather elfin looking people, but the surrealistic tinge to the artwork and its melancholic undertones and fresh interpretations of the RWS tradition mightily impressed me, enough that it became one of my favorite decks.
But there's nothing melancholy or haunting about Hertz' Faerie Tarot. It is unabashed cuteness, flowers, butterflies and light. It perilously approaches Tarot of a Moon Garden's level of unrepentant whimsy. I still need a clearly seasonal deck--especially one with a good autumn-- in my life and thus need a reason to keep from cringing when I handle these cards.
The alien coldness of Hertz' Fantastical Tarot is certainly more appealing now. Go figure. In fact, I've re-enabled myself on that one just from complaining about its effusive younger sibling.
I await your re-enabling.