Hi tarotbear--
I was doing my periodic trawling of our library database for tarot books, and what should be newly listed but It's All in the Cards by one John Mangiapane. Hey! I thought. I think I know that guy! (Well, sort of...)
Very well done. Some things I really like:
I immediately related to your short card descriptions, "This is a card about...." because that echoes my own reading style when I'm reading for others. I'm writing all those down in my tarot notebook. And I agreed with almost all of them.
I loved how you grouped the minors by number rather than suit. It annoys me when books do it the other way. The more I work with the cards, the more I understand the importance of understanding where in a particular cycle the querent might be.
Thank you for including chapters on Life and Year cards! I knew that I have the soul of a Magician, but I never really understood what it meant. (And I had a hard time explaining to my husband his Empress nature.) You provided an important clue to my psyche: as a Magician who has trouble manifesting, I think I need to look at my level of determination.
***SPOILER ALERT***
And finally, I'm still mulling over the sample spread at the end. I love when authors include sample spreads--I think it's an important tool for learning and measuring my progress as a reader--and I was pleased to see that my interpretation was pretty close to your first one. I didn't see your friend's death in the cards either. But in retrospect, perhaps the cards are telling us that physical death is a new beginning. Two aces are powerful indicators of the start of a new cycle. Perhaps rebirth? The Wand could represent a spark of new life, and the Sword conscious awareness of it. Maybe the tarot doesn't predict physical death because from the soul's point of view, it is simply another transition.
I don't really have any critiques for you. I use a different version of the Celtic Cross, but different strokes....
I skipped the card combinations, mainly because so far my (admittedly limited) experience has been that combinations can mean different things in different spreads, and I don't want to limit myself. But that chapter could certainly be a useful resource for those times when I'm stuck. I'll definitely be buying my own copy to have on hand.
Congrats on "manifesting" this book into existence so the rest of us can learn from your experience. Kudos!
Blessings,
Denise