Pam O
I have all 3. I read with all 3. The ToD cards may "feel" flimsy, but they seem to wear very well. The Victorian Romantic and some of the other MRP / Baba deck also "feel" flimsy, but those keep on shuffling and they seem to hold up really well with use according to people who have had them since they were first published, so I feel that the card stock should not be worried about. I personally like the softer feel of the ToD and it is my personal favorite to shuffle.
The Gilded is fabulous for beginners since the art is simplistic. Like people have said, Ciro was quite new to tarot when he designed that deck. I bought the Gilded because people kept saying how wonderful it was, and I figured I wanted to experience it for myself. I got the Legacy deck at Reader's Studio 2010, and that quickly became a favorite. Then I kept reading that people often recommended the "Tarot of Dreams" as their favorite, so I bought that at BATS (Bay Area Tarot Symposium) last Aug from Dan with Tarot Garden. That is probably now my favorite, but I really love the Legacy also. I haven't pulled the Gilded out for a while, so I think I might just do that. Also, I ended up sitting next to Ciro for a lunch at RS10 and he mentioned that the Gilded is one of the very best selling decks of all time. Obviously RWS is #1, but at that time, the Gilded was #2 on the most sales of all time for a deck, and that's pretty impressive also!!!
If you haven't pulled Ciro's cards for a reading, I recommend going and doing a spread. I believe you will discover great wisdom. FYI: I have a ToD spread sitting right behind me that I pulled a couple days ago. It's still sitting out because I'm still getting wisdom from it.
Ciro does not have many of his ToD left. He self published that one, where Llewellyn published the other 2. If you are thinking about it, buy it. It's only $30 and it's going to go up in value when it hits OOP since it's such a cool deck, so it will be much more expensive in the future.
http://www.aeclectic.net/tarot/cards/tarot-of-dreams/
Just my 2 cents...
ETA: I just saw that Gilded Strength card re-done. WOW!!!
The Gilded is fabulous for beginners since the art is simplistic. Like people have said, Ciro was quite new to tarot when he designed that deck. I bought the Gilded because people kept saying how wonderful it was, and I figured I wanted to experience it for myself. I got the Legacy deck at Reader's Studio 2010, and that quickly became a favorite. Then I kept reading that people often recommended the "Tarot of Dreams" as their favorite, so I bought that at BATS (Bay Area Tarot Symposium) last Aug from Dan with Tarot Garden. That is probably now my favorite, but I really love the Legacy also. I haven't pulled the Gilded out for a while, so I think I might just do that. Also, I ended up sitting next to Ciro for a lunch at RS10 and he mentioned that the Gilded is one of the very best selling decks of all time. Obviously RWS is #1, but at that time, the Gilded was #2 on the most sales of all time for a deck, and that's pretty impressive also!!!
If you haven't pulled Ciro's cards for a reading, I recommend going and doing a spread. I believe you will discover great wisdom. FYI: I have a ToD spread sitting right behind me that I pulled a couple days ago. It's still sitting out because I'm still getting wisdom from it.
Ciro does not have many of his ToD left. He self published that one, where Llewellyn published the other 2. If you are thinking about it, buy it. It's only $30 and it's going to go up in value when it hits OOP since it's such a cool deck, so it will be much more expensive in the future.
http://www.aeclectic.net/tarot/cards/tarot-of-dreams/
Just my 2 cents...
ETA: I just saw that Gilded Strength card re-done. WOW!!!